Sunday 25 May 2014

Why oh Why Samsung Galaxy S5

Samsung Galaxy S5 G-S900I Smartphone.
Figure 1: Samsung Galaxy S5 Gold (Notebooks.com Inc, 2014). 

RECOMMENDATION: Not for everyone
ALTERNATIVES: HTC ONE M8

In a word “CHEAP”. Not the price tag but the feel of it. Cheap is what I would describe the Brand New Samsung Galaxy S5 flagship smartphone and it’s a phone you would prefer not to be seen with.

For those that understand the value of $894 let alone $894 for a mobile phone, you’ll soon understand the phrase “NOT value for money”.

Firstly I am a big Android fan and somehow Samsung seems to do it for me better than the other brands such as HTC, Nexus, Sony and LG. The Samsung Galaxy S3 was one of the greatest android smartphones I’ve ever used. I eventually upgraded to the Samsung Galaxy S4 and has stuck with it ever since.

Samsung worked for me primarily due to the ease of the User Interface (UI); yes it’s easier to use than Pure Google Nexus, the physical home button that other android smartphones lack, the long battery life and the incorporation of numpads on top of the keyboard. Samsung’s camera was also somewhat better or as good as the other top flagships like the HTC ONE and Sony Xperia Z1.



Figure 2: Harvey Norman selling the Samsung Galaxy S5 16GB for $894 (Harvey Norman, 2014).



Samsung tried to spruce up the value of its flagship smartphone with useless gimmicks for the S4 like the smart scroll that doesn’t work for nuts. The air view/air gestures are useless in low light conditions and the addition of a TV infrared remote control in a smartphone though was impressive at first for showing off but soon became obvious that its just something for kids and impractical but none the less, the S4 was still the one that worked better for me than the rest of the android smartphones.
Figure 3: The Samsung Galaxy S series from left to right, Samsung Galaxy S5, S4, S3, S2 (Redmond Pie, 2014). 



Now with the new S5, Samsung has repeated its mistakes and possibly made the phone somewhat even worse. Holding a Samsung S5 doesn’t make it feel special in any way, in fact it makes you wonder at the back of your head if it’s a fake phone. Samsung is claiming that despite its physical appearance its operating system combined with the new software’s included makes it something to be marvelled at.

Figure 4: Samsung Galaxy S5 User Interface (UI) (Cyberzone, 2014).
 
Samsung also claims that it is better than other smartphones including that of iPhones because it is water resistant (because they can’t make it waterproof like SONY), it has a heart rate monitor (for which “EVERYONE” has a use for and other companies was incapable of putting it in their flagships) and added security with a fingerprint scanner (for which iPhone has already marketed).

Samsung then further made “impressive progress” with its UI by putting in so many more icons for each function of the phone that it no longer takes a short time to access the settings but longer.

At this point the only competition the S5 has is the HTC ONE M8. I would have to say if I’m going to spend $894 on a phone, I would look at the HTC ONE M8 first. It’s not without flaws either but it’s a much better option to the S5.

In conclusion, the Samsung Galaxy S5 is somewhat a disappointment. I’m not sure if this was one of the main reasons that led to the firing of Samsung S5’s chief designer. I would highly advice you to check out the HTC ONE M8 or just stick with the S4.


Works Cited

1.     Cyberzone. (2014, May 25). Samsung Galaxy S5 Review. Retrieved May 25, 2014, from Samsung Galaxy S5 Review: http://www.smcyberzone.com/reviews/4850
2.     Harvey Norman. (2014, May 25). Samsung Galaxy S5 16GB Smartphone - Black . Retrieved May 25, 2014, from Samsung Galaxy S5 16GB Smartphone - Black : http://www.harveynorman.com.au/samsung-galaxy-s5-smartphone.html
3.     Notebooks.com Inc. (2014, May 25). Gotta Be Mobile. Retrieved May 25, 2014, from ANDROID GALAXY S5 MOBILE SAMSUNG New Verizon Samsung Galaxy S5 Release Planned: http://www.gottabemobile.com/2014/05/07/verizon-samsung-galaxy-s5-release/
4.     Redmond Pie. (2014, May 25). Samsung Galaxy S5 vs S4 vs S3 vs S2 vs S [Size Comparison]. Retrieved May 25, 2015, from Samsung Galaxy S5 vs S4 vs S3 vs S2 vs S [Size Comparison]: http://www.redmondpie.com/samsung-galaxy-s5-vs-s4-vs-s3-vs-s2-vs-s-size-comparison/















No comments:

Post a Comment